The truth is that social media--or any media, really--is difficult as a teacher right now. If you're a breastfeeding mom, you know how it feels when you see or hear someone comment on nursing, when they say it's disgusting or should only be done in the bathroom. You feel attacked, even though they may not be talking about or to you personally. Or if you're a formula feeding mom, you know how it feels when you see or hear someone say that formula is poison or that they'd never feed that to their baby. They might not be talking to you, but it sure feels like they're attacking you.
This is how it feels to be a teacher. This is how it feels when you open up the newspaper and every single day, there's a new proposed law wanting to lower your already low pay, implying that anyone could do your job, stating that most teachers are bad. This is how it feels when you read whole blog posts with people ranting about their child's teacher, attacking his/her classroom rules, discipline calls, and so on. Am I saying that parents shouldn't complain about something they feel a teacher isn't doing right? Absolutely not. I believe that communication between a parent and teacher is one of the key components to a successful education experience. I also believe that that communcation should be done in private. But here's how I feel when it's done on a public forum: I feel ashamed. I feel sad. I feel angry. I feel sick, because if that was me, if I somehow stumbled across a blog post a parent had written about me (and honestly, the internet isn't that big), I would be crushed. Because guess what? Like anyone, teachers are human. Teachers make mistakes. Teachers have days where they have a sick child at home, where they're sleep deprived, where they snap at a student for whispering while they're trying to teach, because the kids haven't been on task all day and they just want to do their job. Does that make it right? No, of course not. Are there bad teachers out there? Yes, of course. Just like there are bad mechanics, bad doctors, bad parents, bad actors.
But for the most part, we care. And this is what makes the current teacher bashing climate so hard. We care. We care more than we should, more than our hearts can handle. We go home at night and cry in the shower about the student who has bruises, the student who is getting bullied, the student who lost a parent, the student who was expelled for dealing drugs, the former student whose name is in the police blotter--could I have saved him? We get told to shut up, we get sworn at, we get disrespected in ways you wouldn't imagine. If we gain weight or get a new hair cut, we're subjected to 150 people who feel they have to make a comment on us. We answer to our students, to their parents, to our own bosses.
We pour our heart and soul into lessons, only to look up in the middle of it to see three kids sleeping, one texting, and two throwing paper at each other. When we do something wrong or when someone disagrees with us, we hear about it instantly. But when we do something right, we almost never hear a thank you.
I won't tell you what teachers make, because I can't tell you better than Taylor Mali does. But I can tell you that we care. That we try. That you might think it's a cushy job because summers are off, but the truth is, we need summers to heal the hurts from the past year, to refresh and recharge so that we can do our best. So, I guess I've been silent and unfollowing people and just keeping to myself because it's taken me this long to find an eloquent way to explain how hard this is right now.... and truthfully, I'm just plain tired. Is it summer yet?



42 comments:
You wrote the perfect words. Words that I myself could not say better. I feel exactly the way you described it. And I too am tired vi would love to print this blog post for all the teachers at my work. And I bet every single one if them would agree with you words. Thank you for writing them!
So, Wall Street created this recession, and who pays? Middle class teachers who are being demonized and losing their jobs because there is no money and the politicians have jumped on the bandwagon of "reform" which is just an excuse to cut school funding and hurt good schools and good teachers in the process.
Off my soap box for a minute or two now...
Oh Erin,
I don't even have the words to tell you both my gratitude for teachers like you but also my frustration and sadness for the treatment you receive. :(
Also, THANK YOU for linking to that Taylor Mali video - I completely, 100% loved it.
My husband is a teacher. He wakes to plan and grade at 5:30 every morning, leaves often before he gets to say good morning to his kids, and returns in the evenings well after 6:00 most days. His pay is so low that he works two or three part-time jobs in the summers to make ends meet. He does it because he loves to teach and because he feels that he can make a difference in the world by doing what he does. I know exactly how you feel. I've been feeling the same way. It makes me sad. And tired.
i feel this so much, erin. it sucks. i think i said it on my facebook that the only thing more exhausting that actually teaching is defending teaching as a profession.
Erin, this is beautiful. So heartfelt and it gives me a better perspective, so thank you.
I know that I have ranted a bit about Seths new teacher and after reading your words, I know I should have not put it out there publicly. Thank you for that gentle reminder.
Love you friend
Erin, I have always said that it takes a really special person to be a teacher. It takes patience and passion and a true love of learning. I could never do it. Well, that's not true. I could but I don't want to do it. And so I thank you and the many others who decide to.
Oh.my.goodness. YES. Absolutely. Exactly.
Thanks for putting into words what is so hard to express. If only everyone could experience and understand what teaching IS. But they would have to have the level of caring that we do during the experience to really get it. To understand why I am up until 1am grading to get papers back quickly so students know how they are doing, then revising a lesson and making the first in a series of daily review sheets I committed to (that the kids asked for) because the AP tests are coming, then up at 5am to work 10 hours away from my daughter again and come home to work into the night all over again. Just trying to help kids. Because we care. So much.
Then to be attacked again and again. To have pay reduced, benefits cut, illegal taxes in-acted then argued over while they hold a portion of our check "just in case" they can win it and keep the money. Hurtful. Demoralizing. And demotivating. How are they going to KEEP the good teachers this way let alone recruit new ones?
love you.
grateful for you. and every single teacher out there like you.
What a perfect summary of this job. Thank you! I am printing this for the teachers' lounges at my school!
you got my support girl, i'm still a teacher at heart. and all this talk about "anyone can do our job" is absolutely insulting! i'm so glad you wrote this post, i can tell it's straight from your heart. from the heart that you care so deeply for your students.
Wow, Wow, Wow! You hit the nail right on the head. Being a teacher I applaud you for finding the perfect words to give the outside world a glimpse into a teachers life. Thank you!! Bravo to you for doing what you do. I have no doubt that you are the kind of teacher that I would be proud for my children to have. There are good teachers out there and you are an example of an exemplary one!! XO
I've been a longtime reader, but rarely comment. My husband is a teacher. Currently, it is 8:36pm and he has been at work since 7am {all day teaching, drama practice and now a parent council meeting}. You have so eloquently put into words all of his own frustrations, and all of the burdens that I carry along with him. Teachers need to be supported. They need to be respected and shown that they matter. I know I'm just one voice, but I want you to know that I respect you. The world needs more teachers like you.
You said it all. This is exactly how I felt when I was in the classroom teaching. Prayingforyou.
Gah, this just makes me so angry and upset. I want to teach my children to always respect and appreciate their teachers. I agree that pretty much every single one of you are some of the hardest working people on the planet.
I'm so sorry that you are feeling this way and I hope that more students and parents get the message and learn to value teachers more.
Wishing I could give you a big hug and a hot fudge sundae. I mean you like ice cream, right?? ;)
xoxo
I was thinking the other day and my heart skipped at you being off in the summer. But in the meantime, I admire you, you offer such a neat perspective that has definitely helped me over time, and I appreciate you for how much heart you put into it all. Teachers are awesome. I want to cry at how much I appreciate my boys' teachers.
Steph
I have plans to go back to school someday to change careers and get into education. But this saddens and scares me, yet at the same time, challenges me to want to do it even more. (my husband, Ryan, is actually going back to school right now to be a teacher)
Teaching seems to be such a fulfilling and rewarding job. But I can clearly see what a HARD job it is in so many ways – emotionally, physically and mentally – and how sometimes it DOESN'T feel rewarding or fulfilling because of all the challenges you mentioned.
Now I wonder if I'll even have the stamina or self-confidence to do it. This definitely gives me a new perspective.
I'm sorry you have to deal with this and I truly respect and praise you for doing what you do. Hang in there.
"Ditto," says the high school teacher from Missouri. You explained it better than I ever could! Good luck and may we make it to the end of May in one piece (and the students too... : D )
This is so perfectly, thoughtfully, Erin-fully written! I hope that from now until early June you find many small victories that keep your tank full enough to do what you do so well - teach. love. inspire & that you find the right balance for eliminating the forces that make it so difficult to keep on keeping on! I miss you friend. I really hope that the summer brings an opportunity to meet up at the lake or something.
this is so so touching. and so true.
teachers are the most underpaid people out there. it drives me insane that actors and sports figures make SO MUCH money. our country is basically saying that entertaining people is more important than educating people. and that's gross.
i have complained before, i'm sure of it. but you are so so right. teachers deserve so much more. and they are human. and they make mistakes. but they are doing something so unbelievably amazing for SO VERY LITTLE.
if i could take you out for a spa day to show my appreciation, i would. XO
i think being brave and speaking honestly like this, in a hostile climate, is an excellent reminder how how important our teachers are. they're doing a hard job, an IMPORTANT job, and they're also people with feelings. know that not everyone feels the way it's portrayed in the media. you are appreciated at least by some.
Thank you! And when I get to my school at 7:00am, even though my "contract" says a) I'm not full time and b) my 1st class isn't until 8:15, I still feel guilty for not being full time and ehlping my colleague. And when I leave at 6:00pm, after a pep band game and 3 parent conferences and several phone calls and I tell a student I can't wait any longer, I also feel guilty. And then I get home... and my girls are going to bed and I haven't seen that for more than 20 minutes at either end of the day. My husband who makes 4x more than me, has a 9-5 job and has 25 days of paid vacation. I have 2 personal days and 5 sick days - which have to be used sparingly, because my students don't have a teacher who can do more than a study hall for them when I'm gone. Summer's off? Sure. After 9 months of 60+ hour weeks, I think that's o.k. not to mention the 30 times I have to come into school to conduct a summer pep band rehearsal, etc. Yes please. Summer come quick.
I despise when people treat teachers badly. You are my personal heroes and I do everything I can to support my kid's teachers. You should be paid SO much more!!! My brother-in-law is a music teacher in NY and just got laid off last week. It's so unfair.
xo. Thank you for reminding us that there is another side to every single story - and that side has as person attached to it too.
I've been a high school teacher for the last 15 years and would echo everything you've said here.
On a side note, we're fortunate to have Taylor Mali visiting our school today and I just got to see him perform live--what a treat!
Hang in there!
Nancy G.
JEALOUS OF ANONYMOUS! How awesome.
Steph
This is such a great post. It makes me SO SAD to see the teacher-bashing that's becoming so acceptable.
AMEN!!!! And despite the work teachers put in, and the little pay they get-- who is going to be blamed in 2014 when NCLB goals have not been met? TEACHERS. And, guess what? Continue to treat teachers this way and we will end up with bad teachers. The good teachers will leave (we already face an attrition rate of 50% over the first five years). Teaching will truly become the catch-all for those who cannot do anything else.
Thank you for sharing this Erin! I am not a teacher and don't even have kids yet, but I'm already concerned with the attitudes I see all around me that if someone's kid got in trouble at school, then surely it is the teacher's fault and not the kid's fault. There are people out there who know that isn't true! Hang in there, and thanks for what you do.
GAH!!! I HATE that you had to write this...I graduated from high school in the late 80s and some of the most influential people in my life were my teachers. From my second and third grade teacher (Mrs. Eileen Wallace), to my seventh grade algebra teacher (Mr. Barry Imsande), to my high school counselor (Mr. Dennis Rozema) and many more that I respected, looked up to and listened to - first because I was TOLD to respect authority and then because I appreciated them.
Sadly parents nowadays just make excuses for their brats and do not feel anyone (their brats) should be held accountable for their actions. Instead, they must blame the teachers who give their lives over to teaching to try to better these "brats" (sorry, I have such a pissy attitude about most kids and their parents nowadays...).
I am so sad that education has become this...I KNOW that you have kids that look up to you and that will remember you, like I remember MY teachers that cared, well throughout their lives....
Oh, Erin.
I do believe you are an amazing teacher (and mother! honestly, you just amaze me.)
On behalf of all those students and parents who might never say what they should, lots and lots of thank yous.
it breaks my heart that teachers have to put up w/ feelings like you describe here. this world is a better place because of men & women like you who do what i would say is one of the toughest jobs there is. and i appreciate you sharing your feelings because it is a much needed reminder to be sure that i let my kids teachers know how much i appreciate them and that i don't just share those feelings w/ my friends or family but with the very ones who need and deserve to hear it! big hugs & lots of love to you!!
I love you, Erin. Teachers ROCK. Especially YOU.
Julie said it so well in a few years when the "reform" doesn't work it will be the teachers fault. I want to finish school and start teaching but after listening to my teacher sister and other teachers. I also agree with the other commenter who say that part of the problem is that respect isn't taught at home anymore, it seems more blame everyone but myself mentality is all that is taught. I have had so many amazing teachers over the years and I am so grateful for all the time and energy that they gave to us as students.
Oh Erin... that's just not fair.
I am so, so appreciative of all the men and women out there teaching our children every day. Thank you for all that you do.
That was awesome!! I've never heard it put that way. But I guess you could could put us homeschooling moms in there somehow. People think that all of us choose to do this cuz we think we're better than the other teachers. But that's not why I do it. :) And I don't criticize teachers. Well, maybe just the ones in my family who criticize me or feel they need to "test" my kids, just to make sure that "Mom's doing her job."
Teachers only get noticed when they're doing something wrong, and that's not right. You guys should get paid WAY more than you do. Keep doing what you're doing. :)
Beautifully said. I felt this when I was teaching, and the climate has only become more hostile in the three years since I left the classroom. I am going to share that Tayler Mali piece on my Facebook...it gave me a huge lump in my throat (which is still there as I'm typing this comment). You, and all the other dedicated, caring teachers that do this day in and day out are true heroes. I so hope someday our cultural value system will change to reflect that truth. Hugs to you, mama.
Crying from this post. This career is heartbreaking.
Well said! Thank you!
I've never seen that video before, but it was amazing.
I taught high school English for two years as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Romania and it was the hardest job I ever had. So hard that I came back from PC never wanting to teach again. Not because it was awful or the kids were terrible, but because I couldn't perform at that level every single day, pour my heart into my work, and get repaid in disrespect. I couldn't hack it.
Those two years left me with a massive respect for teachers who CAN hack it, though. And forever grateful that people like you exist and teach and love what you do, even if you have the occasional bad day. We all do. We're all human. But you guys? You're superhuman in my book.
All I can say is AMEN.
I constantly worry about teaching long term with the current attitudes toward it. Do I love teaching? Yes, there is nothing I would rather do. But defending my profession is more tiresome than my days at school with my students could ever be.
Post a Comment